FOOD FOR THOUGHT - Chicken
I have been feeding my Scotties a raw food diet for some years now. I can say that without any doubt Scotties prefer chicken. In fact they love it! I am still learning more and more about canine nutrition every day. I am still changing my BARF (Bone And Raw Food) recipe as I learn new things. I found an article which I will paste below. It has challenged my beliefs about my Scottie's favourite tucker - chicken.
I used to feed a lot of chicken because of its affordability and availability but I am happy to say that my BARF recipe has a smaller ratio of chicken in it these days. This article does make sense and I just thought it might get you thinking to!
Dana Scott writes: feeding chicken and most other poultry creates two very significant nutritional problems that can cause health issues in dogs.
Dana Scott's article below:
You Are What Your Food Eats
"If it’s true that you are what you eat, the diet that’s fed to chickens is essentially what you’re feeding your dog … whatever the chicken eats, good or bad, is what your dog eats. The chicken is just the middleman. And the chicken’s diet is deplorable".
A Commercial chicken feed ingredient label shows contents include:
dehulled soybean meal
these are leftovers from plants after we humans process them and take all of the oils out.
Commercial chicken feed also contains:
Dried bakery product
Hydrolyzed poultry feathers
Dried bakery product is a mixture of bread, cookies, cake, crackers and flour – which are just waste from human food manufacturing.
The base ingredients are just waste and hold little nutritional value for the chicken. The feed provides calories and little else to the chicken so it needs to be supplemented with synthetic vitamins and minerals, as well as free amino acids to make it food-like.
Now, believe it or not, chickens aren’t supposed to be eating things like cereal, white bread and donuts … even when they’re fortified with vitamins and minerals. And when they do, it spells big trouble for the dog eating those chickens …
The Problem With Omega-6 Fatty Acids
Humans love foods that are high in something called omega-6 fatty acids. That’s because we love snacks and processed foods made with plant oils such as soy, corn and sunflower oils (which are really high in omega-6 fats). And the waste from all of those oils gets ground up and put into chicken feed.
Omega-6 fatty acids have the ability to make hormones in your dog. So does its antagonistic brother, omega-3 fatty acid. But the hormones they each produce have very different jobs.
The omega-6 fatty acids produce hormones that increase inflammation, which is an important part of your dog’s immune response. The hormones produced by omega-3 fatty acids work antagonistically and decrease that inflammation. So a balance between these hormones, and the fatty acids that control them, plays a large role in your dog’s immune system and overall health.
Not surprisingly, birds in the wild don’t eat corn or soybeans. They live on grasses and insects. And as you can see, there’s a huge difference between the natural grasses and bugs the chicken is supposed to eat and the corn and soy waste products he’s forced to eat:
While the foods the chicken is supposed to eat contain more omega-3 than omega-6 fatty acids, corn and soy contain ten times more omega-6 fatty acids. And this fundamentally changes the chicken … it makes the chicken high in omega-6 fatty acids because the chicken is what he eats.
The same applies to your dog. If you feed your dog that omega-6 rich chicken, he’ll get the exact same omega fatty acid imbalance the chicken had. You are what you eat.
And your dog won’t be in very good shape if he eats that chicken. Nearly every chronic disease, from allergies and joint pain to diabetes and kidney disease, is caused by chronic inflammation. And chronic inflammation is caused by a diet that’s high in omega-6 fatty acids and low in omega-3 fatty acids.
Are you starting to see why I don’t feed my dogs chicken? Chicken (and any other poultry) contains the highest amount of omega-6 fatty acids … by a landslide!
Chicken Fat Is Unbalanced
Chicken fat is so unbalanced that it will cause chronic inflammation in your dog and he’ll never be able to eat enough healthy food to recover from it. Compare chicken to other meats you might feed your dog. Remember, the aim is to balance the amount of omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids to avoid chronic inflammation.
While all other animals are reasonably balanced in their fatty acids, chicken is way out of whack and that’s because of the foods we feed them. Beef is also fed grain and waste products so why isn’t beef as high in omega-6 fats?” Good question! The answer is, cattle, lambs and goats eat grass and hay for most of their lives and are only fed grains for the last few weeks of their lives. But chicken, turkey, duck and other poultry are fed those omega-6 rich foods every day for their entire life. The longer an animal is fed omega-6 rich foods, the worse off they are.
Source: Duckett, SK et al, Effects of time on feed on beef nutrient composition. J Anim Sci. 1993 Aug;71(8):2079-88.
This shows how feeding corn, soy and other waste grains to feedlot cattle depletes their omega-3 supplies … and the longer the animal eats them, the more he’s robbed of his valuable omega-3 supplies. And to top it off, his omega-6 supplies increase.
If you take a cow and start feeding them corn, soy and other foods high in omega-6 fatty acids, even for just a few weeks, it changes the cow. That cow will soon start to suffer from chronic inflammation because they have too much omega-6 fatty acid in their diet and not enough omega-3 fatty acid in their diet to produce the hormones that lower that inflammation.
Now imagine the chicken, duck or turkey that’s forced to eat nothing but soy and corn (and donuts and mock cream buns) for his entire life. It demolishes their balance of omega fatty acids. While the grain-fed cow has about 5 times as much omega-6 than omega-3, the poor chicken averages about 20 times more omega-6 than omega-3.
Related: The Ultimate Guide To Balancing Fats
That chronically inflamed, omega-6 filled chicken only got that way because of the food they are eating. Now think what happens when you feed that chicken to your dog …
Can Your Dog Eat Chicken And Be Healthy?
I don’t think your dog can eat a large amount of chicken on a regular basis and not suffer from chronic inflammation. There aren’t any foods that are high enough in omega-3 fats to fix the imbalance … it’s just too high!
Chicken is so high in omega-6 fatty acids that you can’t feed it and hope to get a reasonably healthy balance of fats. Even if you feed a lot of omega-3 rich fish, let’s say half of your dog’s diet, you’ll still end up with 11 times more omega-6 fatty acids than omega-3.
A healthy ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 should be really no more than 5:1.
So if you feed more than a small amount of chicken or duck, which means more than a quarter of your dog’s diet, you’ll never be able to get your dog’s hormones and inflammation under control. You can’t feed chicken as a major part of your dog’s diet and expect really good health and a properly functioning immune system.
Pork is just as bad as chicken … there’s 24 times as much omega-6 in pigs than omega-3. And that’s because pigs are raised and fed the same way.
Turkey isn’t that bad! While chicken and duck suffer some pretty significant increases in omega-6 content, the turkey seems to be more immune to his crappy, grain-filled diet. The omega fatty acid balance in turkey is much more reasonable with only 6 times more omega-6 than omega-3. It’s still a bit high, but you can balance that out with a little fish, rabbit or grass-fed beef.
So how the animal is raised and the foods that he eats can significantly impact the nutrition he gives your dog. And how chickens are raised present one more nutritional challenge for your dog …
No Sun = No Vitamin D
Have you ever seen a pasture full of cows while you were out for a drive? Of course you have! You’ve probably also seen sheep or goats. But what about a pasture full of chickens? You’ve probably never seen one because chickens and other poultry are raised indoors in large buildings (and pigs are too).
While the building keeps predators from getting in, it also prevents something else from getting in … sunshine!
Your dog was built to eat other animals … his pointy teeth and short digestive tract show us this. Another physiological status that tells us he’s a carnivore is his lack of ability to produce his own vitamin D.
Vitamin D is critical to your dog’s health. It prevents skeletal deformities in growing puppies, helps regulate the immune system to control inflammatory diseases (just like omega fatty acids do), helps to prevent cancer and contributes to skin health. Without vitamin D, your dog would be a bit of a mess!
Because your dog can’t manufacture vitamin D, he relies on eating animals that can. Unlike dogs, animals like cows, chickens and other herbivorous animals can manufacture vitamin D from sunshine. And there will be lots of it in their skin, liver and kidneys, where it’s manufactured.
But if your dog is eating animals raised indoors and not in sunlight, those animals will be vitamin D deficient … and your dog will be vitamin D deficient too. If he’s eating a commercial diet, they’ll put some synthetic vitamin D into the food to compensate for this … but if you’re feeding your dog a raw diet that contains a lot of poultry or pork, you need to know he’ll be vitamin D deficient (unless you add some vitamin D to his diet).
Remember, your dog relies on other animals for his vitamin D … if those animals are raised indoors, he’s in trouble and may start to show the symptoms of vitamin D deficiency. And that’s the second reason I no longer feed my dogs chicken.
But with that said, you can add enough vitamin D to your dog’s diet to make up for the lack of it in poultry and pork products. So let’s look at what you can do to boost the vitamin D and the omega-3 content of your dog’s diet if you’re feeding poultry.
Making Chicken (And Pork) Safer For Your Dog
I don’t want to be all doom and gloom … especially when poultry and pork can be the most cost effective parts of your dog’s raw diet! But if you’re going to feed them, you need to know the nutritional holes they create … and how to fix them! So let’s take a look at how we can do that.
Adding Vitamin D
It’s pretty easy to replace the lost vitamin D in your dog’s diet … as long as your dog can tolerate fish. Fish is an excellent source of vitamin D … and unless you’re going to give your dog synthetic vitamin D pills (hint: you really don’t want to do this), fish is really the only way you can salvage your dog’s raw diet if it contains a lot of pork or poultry.
Fish (especially fish liver) is very high in vitamin D and if you feed about 5 to 10% of your raw diet as fish, you can give your dog enough vitamin D to make up for the lack of it in your pork or poultry diet.
And fish will help with something else …
Adding Omega-3 Fatty Acids
Any diet with more than a small amount of chicken, poultry or pork (with the exception of turkey) will have waaaay too much pro-inflammatory omega-6 fatty acids (and will also be too high in polyunsaturated fats). This is a much trickier problem to solve than vitamin D.
Ideally, you don’t want much more than 5 times more omega-6 fatty acids than omega-3 fatty acids … but chicken, poultry and pork can contain up to 30 times more and average about 20:1). And as I mentioned before, you just can’t climb back out of this hole. So what can you do?
Feed chickens raised on a proper diet. Feeding organic, free-range chickens will help. They’ll be fed a food that’s more rich in omega-3 fats and this will in turn make the chicken richer in omega-3 fats. Free ranging chickens may also have access to sunshine and that will help solve your vitamin D problem too (although most free range chickens never see the sun).
Replace your chicken with turkey. Although turkey can be a bit more expensive than chicken, its fats are much better balanced and you’re much less likely to cause chronic inflammation in your dog.
Skip the chicken and pork. This is the most expensive option and it’s the one I’ve chosen for my own dogs. I do give a small amount of organic poultry a few times a month to increase the polyunsaturated fats (beef, goat and lamb are high in saturated fats and low in polyunsaturated fats), but the mainstay of my dogs’ raw diet is animals raised outdoors and on grass. This is the closest I can get to their primordial diet and, since I can swing it financially, this is what I do.
Add fish (but not fish oil) . You can add fish to your dog’s diet if he eats a lot of chicken, duck or pork, but it will never get you into the healthy range. It’s better, but it won’t get you all the way. If that’s your only option, then use it … feed fish several times a week to try to get those fats and hormones as balanced as you can afford. But if you can afford to replace the pork and poultry with beef, rabbit, lamb, deer or other hoofed animals, your dog’s diet will be much less inflammatory. Notice I said fish but no fish oil? Fish oil is just too high in polyunsaturated fats to add to chicken so it’s best to skip it. Plus it’s a processed oil and goes rancid … and you’re feeding a raw diet to avoid processed and toxic ingredients, right?
Related: Is Fish Oil Safe For Dogs?
On the whole, your dog’s raw diet will be much healthier if it includes a lot of red meat. Ruminants (animals with hooves and a special stomach for eating grass) eat better diets and are raised in better environments … and these benefits will be passed up to your dog when he eats them. On the other hand, if you’re feeding a raw diet, even if it includes chicken or pork, you’re already doing your dog a great service and he’s probably enjoying the healthy benefits. But it never hurts to tweak that diet and I hope I’ve given you a few reasons to make these small but important adjustments to your own dog’s raw diet.
What changes will you make to your dog’s next raw meal?
WOW! This article certainly substantiated my concerns about feeding too much chicken to my Scotties. Dana has clarified a lot of things about commercial chicken farming, that I kind of suspected but probably didn't fully understand. It makes sense to me now!
Of course Scotties love chicken! Now I understand why. So when offered a range of meats Scotties will choose chicken. It's just like us when we are offered a range of healthy foods .... and then there is McDonalds or Burger King.
Dana's actual article was backed up by graphs and scientific breakdowns of the nutrient and fat contents of various meats. I have believed for a long time that commercially grown chickens have been a 'nothing' food source but I was not aware of it's potential to cause chronic inflammation.
Luckily my more recent BARF recipes have contained very little poultry but now I will also strive to source turkey rather than chicken for my Scotties.
I also think that it is worth mentioning natural anti-inflammatory supplements like Turmeric and Coconut Oil. Adding Turmeric and Coconut Oil to our Scottie's diet is beneficial in reducing inflammation and can only aid in relieving the chronic inflammation caused by the unbalanced omega oils contained in the chicken we have fed them.
Don't forget to check out www.calanclan.com for more Scottie info!